S&P Global Just Made Ethereum's Centralization Risk a TradFi Concern


In a recent note, S&P Global warned about the concentration risk present in Ethereum as Ether rallied in anticipation of a possible Ether exchange-traded fund (ETF).

"U.S. spot ether ETFs that incorporate staking could become large enough to change validator concentrations in the Ethereum network, for better or worse," S&P analysts wrote in a report published Tuesday. "It is therefore critical to understand how ETF issuers' choices will drive concentration risks."

S&P is right: concentration or centralization risk exists in all crypto. The fact that this is being discussed by traditional finance (TradFi) analysts once again (Morgan Stanley has flagged this before) shows just how much institutional interest there is in crypto post-ETF.

Lido, the largest Ethereum validator with just under 33% stake, and Coinbase, holding 15%, pose potential concentration risks, but a potential ether staking ETFs in the U.S., along-side spot ETFs, may reduce this by opting for institutional custodians and diversifying stakes across multiple entities, S&P analysts wrote in their report.

So, how centralized or concentrated is Ethereum? A good measure for this is the 'Nakamoto Coefficient,' which was first proposed by Balaji Srinivasan and Leland Lee. This measures a blockchain's decentralization by counting the nodes needed to control the chain. The higher the numbers, the better decentralization.

Right now, Ethereum's Nakamoto Coefficient is 2, which indicates serious concentration or centralization risk.

Networks like Aptos, Avalanche, or Polkadot have much higher numbers, indicating much more decentralization – but these protocols aren't being considered for an ETF because the SEC alleged that they are securities.

Parts of Ethereum's decentralization quandary have improved, but improvements elsewhere have been slow and stagnant.

For example, Geth - the most popular execution client for Ethereum - controls well over 60% of the execution client market, According to data from Clientdiversity.org.

Geth stands for "Go Ethereum," and is primarily developed and maintained by the Ethereum Foundation, the main nonprofit that supports Ethereum development. Geth is used to handle transactions, deployment and execution of smart contracts.

This is down from where it once was – when Geth controlled around 80% – but it is still a problem as it's still a supermajority. Meanwhile, Prysm, a competing client, controls around 40% of the consensus client space.

As CoinDesk reported in January, a bug in Ethereum's Nethermind client software knocked out 8% of validators (it now controls 17%), raising concerns about what would occur if the same happened to Geth.

These numbers are improving. Perhaps the anticipation of institutional interest from a possible ETF will expedite the process.

Source : CoinDesk / Feb 22, 2024

rayn.finance logo


240 rue Evariste Galois,

06410 Biot,

Sophia Antipolis

Automata Pay

65-66 Warwick House 4th

Floor, Queen Street, London

England, EC4R 1EB

Automata Pay Europe Ltd

3rd Floor Ormond Building,

31-36 Ormond Quay Upper,

Dublin 7, D07 Ee37

Automata ICO Ltd

Italian Branch

Via Archimede, 161,

00197 Roma


The purchase of digital assets is subject to a high market risk and price volatility. Changes in value can be significant and occur rapidly and without warning. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. The value of an investment and returns can fluctuate both up and down, and you may not recover the amount you invested. RISK WARNING

Automata ICO Limited has a branch in Italy with its registered office at Via Archimede, 161, Roma, Italy, and registered in Italy under number 96550860587 with the Organismo Agenti e Mediatori (OAM) as a Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP).

Automata France SAS is a company registered in France with the company number 902 498 617. Automata FRANCE SAS is registered with the french Financial Market Authority, l’Autorité des marchés financiers (“AMF”), as a provider of Virtual Asset Service Provider under number E2023-087.

Automata Pay Europe Limited is a partner of Modulr Finance B.V., a company registered in the Netherlands with company number 81852401, which is authorised and regulated by the Dutch Central Bank (DNB) as an Electronic Money Institution (Firm Reference Number: R182870) for the issuance of electronic money and payment services. Your account and related payment services are provided by Modulr Finance B.V. Your funds will be held in one or more segregated accounts and safeguarded in line with the Financial Supervision Act. How we keep your money safe.